•  Share this page
  •  About us
  •  Subscribe
  •  Jobs
  •  Advertise
  •  Contact Us

How to crack the design without proper function conundrum


Having stayed in some hotels, built not so far in the past, I begin to question the logic of some technology that I encountered in hotel rooms. Were they installed to maximise guest comfort and convenience?  Enhance operational efficiency? Push for premium room rates or merely to layer high-tech gadgets and hotel amenities that someone thought clever.

 

While designed to feel futuristic, they often end up frustrating guests by creating problems that need not exist. Many were the times I was left baffled, curios or irritated after being stuck in a room trying to figure out how to bypass one of these systems? Honestly, it made me think out aloud “Have the people who packed this hotel room with technology ever actually stayed in the room?”  Do they really understand user-centered hospitality? I would love to be a UX researcher for the hotel industry to help shape the guest journey.

 

Here are some very real examples that scream out “take some aspirin on your next trip” to relieve the mild-to-moderate tension headaches, when having to spend several minutes just trying to figure out how the ‘features” creep that is now everywhere, works!

 

For instance, curtains that automatically open when you enter the room - absolutely cool when you first enter the room: But when the curtains open themselves, as you get back to the room after a late dinner at night, all ready to hit the sack, it’s pretty annoying to have to close them again. It’s hard to blame the curtains. To be fair, the sensor can't tell a 3pm arrival from a midnight return to the room. Whoever signed it off to be installed probably saw it in an empty room in daylight. A feature like that gets swiftly approved at handover, when nobody has tested it out at night.

 

People go ga ga when hotels boast of rooms equipped with thermostats that use motion sensors to determine if you are in the room or not. The problem surfaces late night when you sleep completely still, when the system assumes the room is empty and turns off the AC, waking you up sweating at 3am. Then there are rooms where the interfaces let you press a button to lower the room temperature, only to bounce back after a while, to a pre-programmed energy-saving default (like 23°C/74°F) because the hotel overrides user preferences.

 

For me, the most ridiculous feature has got to be the Glass-Wall gimmick of installing a pane of glass between the bedroom and bathroom instead of building a proper wall, guarded by a flimsy blind that, over time, never quite fully closes. Some hotels have taken it to another level by installing smart glass walls between the bathroom and the bedroom that turn opaque at the press of a button. Now should the power blink or there be a systems glitch, your privacy suddenly becomes entirely transparent. Even more ridiculous is when you encounter this in resort-style hotels where families are definitely going to be sharing the room.

 

Which is less sinister? The circa 35 light switches in the room, each for a different adornment, the bed head, overhead, corridor, balcony, bathroom light, etc. that is harder to figure out than the Rubik Cube, or the  ‘All-or-Nothing button’ - a single bedside switch labeled "Master" that shuts off all the lights. The problem: It frequently cuts power to the desk outlets so that you wake up in the morning to a dead battery in the phone or laptop that you plugged on to charge overnight.

 

My pet irritation – showers; While some people use Sudoku to exercise their brains I truly believe one can also benefit from the problem solving challenges that come with so many hotel showers. When faced with the puzzle in a new hotel room’s bathroom how do you approach it? Should it be turned, pulled or pushed to make that rain shower rain?

 

Many of us have also learned through spluttering experience that it’s a good idea to hold onto the hand held shower and have it facing away from you before touching a thing. Simply pointing it at the wall quickly falls apart as a strategy when the sudden water pressure is strong enough to spin it towards you, covering the entire bathroom in water as it goes. What of the ‘child lock’ button on the telephone shower that can frustrate all your efforts?

 

Depending on where you are in the world blue and red may not mean what they do back home, and the letter C on a tap could be C for cold, or C  for Caldo (Italian) or Calient (Spanish),  which means hot.

 

Ilzaf Keefahs is a freelance writer who enjoys focusing on hospitality related matters that he is passionate about, and likes to share his views with hoteliers and customers alike. He delves into the heart of hospitality to figure out both customer service and consumer trends that impact the industry.

 



INTERESTING LINK
HSL LinkedIn
CLICK HERE

Subscribe